Ask A Christian

In this episode of the Ask A Christian Podcast, host Nate and the crew plow through a week-plus of Christianity-related news with the usual mix of seriousness, Scripture, and light Babylon Bee-style irony.We open with the Lindsay Clancy murder trial: the Massachusetts mother who strangled her three young children, jumped out a window, and now faces a postpartum psychosis + overmedication defense. Feminists and online voices have turned her into a folk hero against “the patriarchy,” raising nearly a million dollars. Nate asks the uncomfortable questions about demons, accountability, spiritual rot, and why celebrating the killing of children outside the womb is treated differently than abortion. (More at: https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/lindsay-clancy-murder-trial-update-9.7303583 and https://humanevents.com/2026/08/17/posobiec-lindsay-clancy-child-killer-case-exposes-how-feminism-socialism-poisons-womens-brains)A new listener, Pond, asks the practical question many wonder: Can Christians take medications (including for autism or mental health)? The answer from Scripture and common sense is yes—God gave us doctors and medicine (think Paul’s advice to Timothy about wine for the stomach). Informed consent and wisdom still apply; cults that ban it are outside biblical Christianity.Then a progressive Episcopal church in Michigan runs a gun buyback for Kroger gift cards to “protect children,” while remaining proudly pro-choice. Cue discussion of the Second Amendment’s actual purpose (tyranny prevention), Jesus telling the disciples to buy a sword, the difference between murder and justified killing, and why beating swords into plowshares is an end-times promise, not a current disarmament mandate. (Story: https://protestia.com/2026/08/17/progressive-church-holds-gun-buyback-event-to-tackle-violence-and-unnecessary-deaths/)Heartwarming interlude: rising Disney/Hollywood star Malachi Barton publicly thanks his parents for keeping God at the center and quotes Joshua 1:9. Praise God for the youth.Later we hit deconstruction TikTok: a woman claims her pastor “groomed” and manipulated her… by telling her not to dress like a prostitute or talk like a sailor. Nate, Steph, Lou and others unpack actual biblical modesty (1 Timothy 2, 1 Peter 3, Romans 14 catch-all, bodies as temples), purity-culture excesses vs basic human dignity, and the victim Olympics.The main event the user flagged: a gay man in a supermarket loses it over a polite Christian handing him a simple tract about becoming the person God created him to be. “Stop evangelizing!” he demands—while Pride Month inserts itself into every public space, school, and parade. The crew contrasts Christian kindness with the cultural double standard, discusses what actual hate would look like, and lands on the Great Commission. Hypocrisy noted with appropriate eye-rolls.Also touched: Ms. Rachel’s reparations push, denying God’s Fatherhood, and more. Serious faith topics, playful jabs, zero fluff.For more content, visit: https://www.askachristianpodcast.com📚 Resources & Links• Lindsay Clancy trial overview: https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/lindsay-clancy-murder-trial-update-9.7303583• Posobiec on feminism/socialism and the Clancy case: https://humanevents.com/2026/08/17/posobiec-lindsay-clancy-child-killer-case-exposes-how-feminism-socialism-poisons-womens-brains• Ms. Rachel reparations: https://resistthemainstream.com/wait-what-incredibly-popular-controversial-youtuber-ms-rachels-latest-little-stunt-dominates-headlines/Timestamps00:00 - Intro01:01 - Lindsay Clancy trial & postpartum psychosis defense05:44 - Feminists celebrating Clancy as icon / spiritual rot11:46 - Sean on demonic aspects & church failure15:15 - Can Christians take medications? (Pond’s question)21:41 - Progressive church gun buyback event27:56 - Why guns are legal in America / biblical self-defense33:30 - Disney star Malachi Barton praises Jesus & parents1:14:00 - Deconstruction TikTok: pastor “groomed” me by teaching modesty1:21:50 - Bible verses on modesty & wholesome speech1:28:11 - “Stop evangelizing!” gay man’s supermarket tract rant1:35:20 - Pride Month hypocrisy vs Christian witnessing1:49:39 - Close & next weekHashtags#AskAChristianPodcast #Christianity #Bible #Faith #Jesus #Apologetics #Gospel #LindsayClancy #PostpartumPsychosis #ChristianModesty #Deconstruction #Evangelism #SelfDefense #2ndAmendment #ChristianLife

Are Protestants a Cult? Praying to Saints & One Mediator DebateDescriptionIn this TikTok Thursday episode of the Ask A Christian Podcast, host Nate fields a fiery call from a Maronite Catholic in Lebanon who labels Protestantism a cult worse than Islam—then pivots hard into praying to saints, the Virgin Mary, saintly miracles, and whether Catholics can be saved.Nate pushes back with sola scriptura, the first-century church in Acts, and 1 Timothy 2:5’s “one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus.” The conversation digs into apostolic succession, early church fathers, the Apocrypha vs. the 27-book New Testament canon, and whether rejecting Catholic tradition makes you “accountable.”A caller brings up Ben Shapiro and Alex O’Connor agreeing God can’t be proven or disproven—prompting Nate’s take on faith, historical evidence, fulfilled prophecy, and the Holy Spirit’s confirmation. Later stretches tackle Jesus’ knowledge of “the day and the hour,” the hypostatic union, temptation in the wilderness, and practical advice for a brand-new Christian asking how to pray the rosary.Serious theology meets light, Babylon Bee-style irony as callers trade accusations, history lessons, and leftover-taco gratitude. If you’ve ever searched “is praying to saints biblical,” “are Protestants a cult,” “can Catholics be saved,” or “does Jesus know the day and hour,” this one’s for you.For more content, visit: https://www.askachristianpodcast.comTimestamps00:00 - Intro00:23 - Catholic caller: Protestants are a cult02:19 - Bible alone vs. man-made traditions03:25 - Do you follow the Virgin Mary?04:16 - Saints, miracles, and devotion10:28 - One mediator: why not pray to saints13:40 - Ben Shapiro, Alex O’Connor & proving God20:38 - Can Catholics be saved? Accountability for rejecting Catholicism23:46 - Church history, Peter the rock & early fathers27:06 - Protestant roots, Luther & the 1500s32:11 - Apostolic succession & laying on of hands34:46 - Traditions in 2 Thessalonians vs. later additions1:15:18 - Does Jesus know the day and the hour?1:18:37 - Temptation of Jesus & can God be tempted1:44:12 - New Christian asks how to pray the rosaryHashtags#AskAChristianPodcast #PrayingToSaints #OneMediator #CatholicVsProtestant #SolaScriptura #ApostolicSuccession #CanCatholicsBeSaved #ChristianApologetics #BibleAlone #HypostaticUnion #JesusKnowsTheHour #FaithVsEvidence #Christianity #Jesus #Bible

How did we actually get the New Testament canon — and no, it wasn't handed down by Rome or Constantinople. Nate breaks down the real history of Bible canonization: from the books circulating as early as the mid-100s, to the Muratorian fragment, to Athanasius's famous 367 AD Festival Letter listing all 27 books, to the later councils of Hippo and Carthage that simply recognized what the church had already agreed on for centuries. Spoiler: the Catholic and Orthodox churches didn't hand Protestants a Bible — the Holy Spirit did.
Along the way, the panel dives into fresh manuscript evidence backing New Testament reliability, plus why it's usually Muslim apologists (not atheists) who go hardest after the Bible's textual history — a bit rich, considering the Quran's own manuscripts were burned to force uniformity.
The conversation then shifts into a hard look at Islam: the marriage of Aisha to Muhammad, Iraq's recent legal changes lowering the marriage age to nine for girls, the treatment of women under Sharia law, and how Islam spread historically — often by the sword — compared to the voluntary spread of the Gospel through Europe and into America. The panel also tackles the tough question: should a "world-conquering" ideology like Sharia have a place in a free society, and what's really happening with Islamic immigration in places like Brooklyn and the UK?
Serious theology, some Babylon Bee-level sarcasm, and zero patience for double standards — that's the Ask A Christian Podcast.
For more content, visit: https://www.askachristianpodcast.com
Timestamps
00:00 - Intro00:33 - Preview: Bible canon, church news, and more01:52 - Why the Bible canon debate matters08:20 - Athanasius and the Festival Letter of 367 AD10:13 - The 27 books of the New Testament canon13:50 - Why the Holy Spirit — not church councils — decided the canon29:37 - Continued discussion: manuscript evidence for the New Testament31:12 - Muslims and attacks on Bible textual reliability45:06 - Transitioning to Islam: is child marriage justified?46:22 - Iraq lowers the legal marriage age to nine1:00:41 - Women's rights, honor killing, and inequality in Islam1:02:32 - How the Middle East became Muslim by the sword1:07:46 - How the Gospel reached Europe and America1:09:15 - Should Islam be banned in America?1:12:51 - Islamic immigration in Brooklyn, NYC, and the UK
Hashtags (15)
#AskAChristianPodcast #BibleCanon #NewTestamentCanon #ChristianApologetics #Christianity #Bible #ChurchHistory #Athanasius #Islam #IslamVsChristianity #Quran #Apologetics #Faith #BibleStudy #ChristianVsMuslim

Is LGBTQ a cult? That question set the internet on fire during this Tik Tok Tuesday episode of the Ask A Christian Podcast, and host Nate doesn't back down — pulling actual peer-reviewed cult criteria (Lifton and Singer) and running down the list live, point by point, against a self-identified member of the "rainbow" who insists there's no leader, so it can't possibly qualify.
But that's far from the only thing on the table. Nate opens with a rapid-fire defense of substitutionary atonement and the wrath of God (following up on a marathon debate from the day before), then fields a string of listener questions on whether Christians are grafted into Israel, whether the modern political state of Israel still holds biblical significance, and why Christians shouldn't pray to saints or venerate icons — no matter how good the basketball-team analogy sounds.
Later, an atheist and an agnostic both come up to challenge the panel on the existence of God, cosmology, and the reliability of the Bible versus the Quran, leading to one of the more in-depth apologetics exchanges the show has had in a while. Deconstruction gets called out as "for petulant children" (again), and yes, the LGBTQ cult conversation gets a full second round before the episode wraps.
Buckle up — it's a long one, and it does not slow down. For more content, visit: https://www.askachristianpodcast.com
Timestamps00:00 - Intro00:29 - Substitutionary Atonement & the Wrath of God06:45 - Are Christians Grafted Into Israel? (Old vs. New Covenant)12:12 - Does the Land of Israel Belong to the Jews?18:30 - Are Christians Under the Law of Moses?20:15 - Should Christians Support the Modern State of Israel?22:42 - Why We Shouldn't Pray to Saints28:50 - Original Sin & Paul's Rebuke of Peter in Galatians34:57 - Is Deconstruction Just for "Petulant Children"?38:24 - Are Icons a Form of Idolatry?47:41 - Is LGBTQ a Cult?1:02:14 - The 5 Signs You're In a Cult1:13:14 - Debating an Atheist: Does God Exist?1:30:14 - Jesus vs. Allah: Comparing the Bible and the Quran1:36:26 - Continued Discussion: Is LGBTQ a Cult?Hashtags (15)
#AskAChristianPodcast #IsLGBTQACult #LGBTQ #Christianity #Bible #ChristianApologetics #Apologetics #Atheism #DoesGodExist #PrayingToSaints #Icons #OldCovenant #Deconstruction #Israel #Faith

In this episode of the Ask A Christian Podcast, Nate and the panel dig into two of the thorniest debates in Christian theology: penal substitutionary atonement (PSA) vs. Christus Victor, and the identity of the "spirits in prison" in 1 Peter 3:19.
It starts with a real-world flashpoint — a wave of anti-Calvinist TikTok and Clubhouse Christians branding PSA as heretical. The panel unpacks what's actually at stake: is the problem the "penal" (legal, punishment-based) framing, or substitutionary atonement itself? They walk through Old Testament sacrifice, the meaning of "atonement" as reunification rather than restitution, whether God's wrath and the "wages of sin" require a punishment-based framework, and how Christus Victor's picture of Christ's triumph over sin, death, and hell fits (or doesn't fit) alongside PSA. Expect real disagreement, some Old Testament deep-dives on purity rituals, and a debate over whether the old covenant closed at the cross or the resurrection.
From there, the conversation shifts to 1 Peter 3:18-20 — the famously difficult passage where Jesus "preached to the spirits in prison." Who are these spirits? Human souls from Noah's day? Fallen angels chained in Tartarus (2 Peter 2:4, Jude 6)? Old Testament saints released from Sheol? The panel walks through the major interpretive options — including the Calvin/Reformers' view that Christ preached through Noah — and wrestles with 1 Peter 4:6 and whether any of this implies a "second chance" for salvation after death.
If you've ever wondered what "PSA" even means, whether Christus Victor and penal substitution can coexist, or who Jesus was actually talking to between his death and resurrection, this episode is for you.
For more content, visit: https://www.askachristianpodcast.com
Timestamps
00:00 - Intro5:12 - PSA (penal substitutionary atonement) debate introduced8:34 - Steph: Christus Victor vs PSA9:48 - Is substitutionary atonement required to be a Christian?10:36 - The critique of the "penal" in PSA17:57 - Atonement as reunification, not punishment22:04 - Does the Old Testament show God's wrath satisfied by sacrifice?1:01:07 - The real divide: PSA vs. a purification-based view1:07:42 - Transition: Jesus preaches to those in Sheol1:09:04 - What was Jesus actually preaching after death?1:24:04 - 1 Peter 3:19 vs 2 Peter 2:4: who are the "spirits in prison"?1:26:28 - Reading 1 Peter 3:19 in context1:36:32 - Scholarly consensus on the Greek word for "preached"1:37:11 - 1 Peter 4:6 and the "second chance" question1:39:36 - Calvin's view: Christ preached through Noah1:40:24 - The fallen angels / Genesis 6 Watchers interpretation
Hashtags (15)
#AskAChristianPodcast #ChristianApologetics #Atonement #PenalSubstitution #ChristusVictor #1Peter3 #SpiritsInPrison #Theology #Christianity #Bible #BibleStudy #ReformedTheology #Soteriology #WhatIsTheGospel #DoctrineOfHell

It’s Friday at the Ask A Christian Podcast with host Nate, so let your hair down and join us for a wild mix of caller questions, culture reviews, and deep-dive theology!
In this episode, we tackle a probing caller question: What did Jesus actually mean when He asked, "Why do you call me Lord, and do not do what I say?" We discuss the stark difference between verbal profession and authentic obedience.
Then, the team plays a game straight out of an internet meme: "Does White Privilege Exist or Is It Racist?"—with everyone jumping in for some Friday fun and hot takes.
Later in the show, we dive into current culture and church news:
UMC Ideological Drift: How the United Methodist Church has completely lost the plot with their pride pins, stickers, and theological compromise.
TikTok Atheism Response: We critique and respond to the absolute lowest tier of internet atheism TikTok has to offer, breaking down bottom-of-the-barrel arguments with biblical clarity and a healthy dose of satire.
Finally, we address a controversial debate currently raging online: Can Calvinists be Christian? Responding to rabid anti-Calvinists claiming that Calvinists are in a cult and incapable of salvation, we return to the core of the Gospel. While secondary issues like free will, election, and predestination are heavily debated, being wrong on a secondary doctrine does not put someone's eternal soul in jeopardy.
Jesus made it clear that salvation requires being born again. As Apostle Paul writes in Romans 10:9–10:
"If you confess with your mouth that Jesus is Lord and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved. For with the heart one believes and is justified, and with the mouth one confesses and is saved."
God knows the hearts of all people, and a tree is ultimately known by its fruit.
For more content, visit: https://www.askachristianpodcast.com
🏷️ Hashtags#AskAChristianPodcast #Christianity #BibleStudy #Theology #Jesus #Gospel #Calvinism #Apologetics #TikTokAtheism #ChristianPodcast #Faith #BiblicalTruth #Methodist #Romans109 #ChristianLiving

In this episode of the Ask A Christian Podcast, grumpy host Nate is already over Florida bugs, school drop-off chaos, and Ace Hardware small talk before diving into the real stuff. Continued discussion on the Massachusetts law that effectively opens the door to abortion up to birth (physician judgment after 24 weeks) leads to a blunt take: this isn’t “anti-woman” or “anti-healthcare”—it’s anti-murder. Life begins at conception (or at the very least a heartbeat), late-term procedures are still a delivery with needless suffering, and calling it anything else doesn’t change the reality. Michael pushes back from a non-religious, “healthcare is a right / I don’t have a uterus” angle, while Nate and the crew hold the line that murder doesn’t get a special exception just because the victim is inside someone.Along the way Nate vents about an Orthobro TikTok debate that went sideways—apostolic succession, tradition battles, and how the Holy Spirit (not guys in robes or councils) is why we have a reliable New Testament canon that every major Christian tradition already agrees on for the gospel. Later the conversation turns to Independent Fundamental Baptist / Way of Life literature standards: strict modesty rules, no pants for women, KJV-only vibes, separation from culture, and whether those lines are biblical or just extra.Plus the usual first-world suffering, meme scrolling, and reminders that the gospel is still the only real hope. For more content, visit: https://www.askachristianpodcast.comTimestamps00:00 - Intro03:10 - Orthobros, canon, tradition & apostolic succession09:25 - School drop-off, Florida bugs & weed-killer saga18:05 - Massachusetts late-term law & continued abortion discussion22:35 - Is it anti-woman or anti-murder?27:30 - Why late-term abortion makes no medical sense32:30 - Michael’s fine line: personal pro-life, public non-imposition50:00 - Way of Life / IFB dress codes, modesty & separation56:00 - Pants, tightness, tattoos & “Dressing for the Lord”1:03:20 - Flooding updates & more IFB reflections1:06:40 - Memes, satire & wrapping upHashtags#AskAChristianPodcast #Christianity #Bible #Faith #Jesus #Apologetics #Gospel #Abortion #ProLife #Abolition #Orthodox #EasternOrthodox #IFB #Modesty #ChristianLife

Massachusetts just made headlines by legalizing abortion up to birth—and Nate breaks down Governor Healey's new law, why it goes further than most people realize, and where both the pro-life and pro-choice camps fall short of an honest, consistent ethic. From there the show takes a hard left turn into human brain organoids: scientists really are growing lab-cultured human brain tissue and wiring it into biocomputers to replace power-hungry silicon chips. Is this the next leap for AI, or something closer to a horror movie premise? Michael, Mark, and the panel dig into what organoids are actually used for, what makes something a "cyborg," and whether a synthetic brain could ever be more than a very convincing counterfeit of consciousness.
The conversation then turns philosophical: can a secular "reduce harm and suffering" framework actually answer hard ethical questions, or does it eventually run into a wall that only Scripture can address? The panel stress-tests that question against abortion, ectopic pregnancies, and the hypocritic—er, Hippocratic—oath. The episode wraps with a disturbing story out of Cincinnati involving the murder of a 7-year-old boy, a sobering reminder of why these conversations matter.
This is Ask A Christian Podcast, where Nate and the panel dive into apologetics, culture, and the hard questions—biblical and otherwise—that everyone's afraid to ask out loud.
📚 Resources & Links
Governor Healey Signs Legislation Strengthening Abortion Protections in Massachusetts: https://www.mass.gov/news/governor-healey-signs-legislation-strengthening-abortion-protections-in-massachusettsFinal Spark biocomputing overview: https://finalspark.com/Final Spark - Biocomputing: The Next Evolutionary Leap: https://finalspark.com/biocomputing-the-next-evolutionary-leap/Cortical Labs - actual intelligence beyond silicon: https://corticallabs.com/Viral abortion clinic doctor confrontation video: https://www.reddit.com/r/PublicFreakout/comments/e76orr/craziness_ensues_when_an_abortion_doctor_comes/"Trans" Gang Murders 7-Year-Old Boy in Ohio: https://resistthemainstream.com/red-state-murder-horror/
For more content, visit: https://www.askachristianpodcast.com
Timestamps
00:00 - Intro0:36 - Massachusetts Passes Extreme Late-Term Abortion Law7:18 - Where Pro-Life and Pro-Choice Both Fall Short9:32 - Do We Only Use 10% of Our Brain? (Myth Debunked)11:28 - "AI Is Dead, Organoids Are Here": Growing Brains for Computing14:26 - What Scientists Actually Use Organoids For20:18 - Final Spark's Pitch for Biocomputing26:02 - What Actually Makes Someone a Cyborg?29:00 - Where Christian Ethics Draws the Line32:15 - Could You Buy a Human Brain Computer?36:30 - AI "Resurrections" of Deceased Loved Ones (Lookalike.com)39:22 - Secular Harm Reduction vs. Biblical Ethics41:47 - Does "Reduce Harm and Suffering" Justify Abortion?50:22 - Ectopic Pregnancies and the Triage Argument1:01:52 - "Trans Gang" Murder of a 7-Year-Old Boy in Ohio
Hashtags (15)
#AskAChristianPodcast #AbortionUpToBirth #Massachusetts #ProLife #Christianity #Bible #Apologetics #Organoids #Biocomputing #AI #ChristianEthics #Atheism #Faith #Ethics #Abortion